Every part of the lens makes the whole picture
It feels obvious that the top of a lens makes one part of the picture and the bottom makes another, like tiles in a mosaic. A lens doesn’t work that way.
Light leaves every point of an object in all directions. Take a lamp: its top edge sends light to the top of the lens, the middle and the bottom, everywhere at once. A lens bends all of those rays so that they meet again at one point on the screen, the image of that top edge. The same happens for every other point of the lamp.
Now slide a card over the top half of the lens. The light from the lamp’s top edge that went through the bottom half still arrives at the same image point. So does the light from every other point. Every part of the picture is still there. Each point just gets less light than before. A 2022 concept test for lenses by Salome Wörner and colleagues (Physical Review Physics Education Research) puts the correct idea in one line: covering the lens partly “does not affect the image (except for making it less bright)”.
Physics teachers put this on stage
This is a classic lecture demonstration, because the result surprises almost everyone. Purdue University’s demonstration notes describe it: project a light bulb onto a screen with a big lens, then slowly lower a card in front of the lens. The image “will get dimmer, but remain complete” until the lens is fully blocked. The notes even suggest asking the class first which part of the upside-down image will vanish, and promise “considerable surprise”.
The University of Colorado Boulder runs the same demonstration, blocking half the lens with cardboard, to tackle “the common misconception that different parts of a lens form different parts of the image”. Idaho State University goes further and covers the middle of a large lens with a paper disc. The whole image is still on the screen, only dimmer.
You use this every day
A camera does it on purpose. Its diaphragm is a ring of blades that closes down to a smaller hole in the middle of the lens. Wikipedia’s article on apertures explains that this controls how much light reaches the sensor; each full f-stop halves the light. Your photos don’t lose their edges when you close the aperture. They get darker, so the camera keeps the shutter open longer. The pupil of your eye is the same kind of opening, so your view of the room doesn’t shrink when your pupils get smaller in bright light.
Big reflecting telescopes are an even bolder example. Their secondary mirror hangs on struts in the path of the incoming light, in front of the main mirror. The mirror and its struts block some of the light, and the struts add the cross-shaped spikes you see around bright stars in many telescope pictures. But there is no hole in the picture where the mirror sits.
When a card does cut the picture
Where you put the card matters. Hold it right at the lens and the whole image dims. Hold it right at the screen, where the image forms, and it simply covers that part of the picture, like a hand in front of a cinema screen. A blocker somewhere in between does a bit of both, and can darken the picture towards one edge; photographers call that kind of darkening vignetting. The myth comes from treating a card on the lens as if it were a card on the picture.
Why the myth feels so right
Our everyday intuition is about shadows: block part of a lamp and part of the wall goes dark. It also seems natural that an image is a little copy of the object that travels through the lens and gets flipped. Wörner and colleagues collected these ideas from earlier research, including “A half lens produces a half image” and “When half of a lens is covered, half the light rays from the object are blocked, so only half of its image appears”. The second one starts with something true. Half the light is blocked. It just isn’t half of the picture.
The upside-down answer is a clever version of the same idea. In a 2017 study, Merlin John, Jacob Molepo and Max Chirwa asked 70 Grade 11 learners in Mthatha, South Africa, what happens to the image on a screen when the upper half of the lens is covered. 46 said the upper half of the image would disappear. 10 said the lower half would, because the image is upside down. One learner explained that “when the image is formed, it is formed upside down so the lower part will not be displayed”. Only one of the 70 gave the right answer: the image gets dimmer. The authors point out that studies since the 1980s found the same idea, often even after teaching.
It isn’t only students, either. A University of Maryland collection of physics problems carries this one as “The half lens”, with a note to teachers: “Most people (not just students) expect that you will only get half of the image.”
Try it at home
You need a magnifying glass and a sheet of white paper. Stand across the room from a bright window, hold the paper behind the magnifier and move it back and forth until a sharp, small, upside-down picture of the window appears. Now cover half of the magnifier with your other hand. The window stays whole, and the picture gets darker. Then cover all but a small gap, and you will still see the whole window, quite dim.
The full story of how lenses form images, why you don’t even need the paper, and how your eye does all this, is on our page about how lenses work.