Half the Moon is always lit
The Moon makes no light of its own. The Sun shines on it from one side, so at any moment one half of the Moon is in daylight and the other half is in night. As NASA puts it, “the Sun always illuminates half of the Moon while the other half remains dark, but how much we are able to see of that illuminated half changes as the Moon travels through its orbit.”
That is the whole trick. When the Moon is on the far side of Earth from the Sun, its sunlit half faces us: full Moon. When it is between us and the Sun, the sunlit half faces away: new Moon, which we can’t see at all. Everything in between is a slice of the lit half, seen from the side. The cycle takes about 29.5 days.
Try it with a lamp and a ball in a dark room. Hold the ball at arm’s length and turn slowly on the spot. You’ll watch it go from crescent to half to full and back, and your head never shades it, except at the one moment when your head is right between the ball and the lamp.
The giveaway: where is the Sun?
Earth’s shadow points straight away from the Sun. So it can only ever reach the Moon when the Moon is on the opposite side of the sky from the Sun.
But look at when we see a thin crescent. A new Moon, NASA notes, is “in the same part of the sky as the Sun”, and the waxing crescent after it “rises in the morning after the Sun is up, and sets at night after the Sun is down”. So you catch it in the evening, low in the sky, not far from where the Sun just set. A Moon that close to the Sun is nowhere near Earth’s shadow. The Belgian astronomers who surveyed people about this put it simply: “simple observations readily show the Moon to be a thin crescent when close to the Sun, and full when opposite to it” (Nazé & Fontaine).
There’s a lovely bonus. During a crescent, the “dark” part of the Moon often glows faintly. That glow is earthshine: sunlight bouncing off Earth onto the Moon. Far from darkening the Moon, Earth is lighting it up.
When Earth’s shadow really does hit the Moon
It happens, and it has a name: a lunar eclipse. NASA explains that “lunar eclipses occur at the full moon phase”, when Earth sits between the Sun and the Moon and its shadow falls on the Moon, “dimming it and sometimes turning the lunar surface a striking red over the course of a few hours.”
So the two things look nothing alike. Phases come round every month and change slowly over days. An eclipse happens only at full Moon, only in some months (the Moon’s orbit is tilted, the same reason NASA gives for a new Moon usually not passing straight in front of the Sun, so a full Moon usually slips just above or below the shadow), and it is over in a few hours.
Why the myth feels so right
Something dark is creeping across a bright ball, and shadows make things dark. It’s a perfectly reasonable guess, and eclipses, which really are shadows, make it more convincing.
You’re in big company. In a study published in 2000, Ricardo Trumper gave 76 students starting a university astronomy course in Israel two drawings of the Moon a few nights apart. 31.6% said the change happens because the Moon moves into Earth’s shadow; 51.3% chose the right answer. In the same class, 71.1% thought a total solar eclipse needs a full Moon (it needs a new Moon; test yourself on that one). In a survey of students of all levels in Belgium in 2012, about 40% of those who said the phases change over a night or a month blamed Earth’s shadow.
If you got it wrong, you now know something many university students didn’t. And next time you see a crescent, look for the Sun nearby. It’s never far away.