Ten minutes of Mozart

The story starts with a one-page letter in Nature in 1993. Frances Rauscher and her colleagues Shaw and Ky reported that college students did better on reasoning tasks right after listening to Mozart’s Sonata for Two Pianos in D major, K. 448.

As a 1999 review summed it up, ten minutes of the sonata raised the students’ scores by the equivalent of 8 or 9 IQ points, compared with listening to relaxation instructions or to silence. Notice what that sentence doesn’t say. The listeners were students, not babies. The gain was measured straight after the music, and it was temporary. In a 1995 follow-up the same team described it as a “short-term enhancement of spatial-temporal reasoning”: the kind of thinking you use to picture how a folded, cut piece of paper will look when you open it again.

That is a long way from “classical music makes you smarter”. But the catchy version is the one that travelled.

Then everyone tried it

A result this startling invites other labs to check it, and many did. In 1999 the psychologist Christopher Chabris pooled what they had found in a meta-analysis in Nature: 20 published comparisons of Mozart against silence, involving 714 people.

The average gain was 0.09 standard deviations, or “only 1.4 IQ points”. On the abstract-reasoning tasks it was zero (slightly negative, in fact). On the spatial tasks it was 2.1 IQ points, and even that wasn’t statistically significant. For scale, Chabris noted that a single person’s IQ score wobbles more than that from one test to the next.

In the same issue, Kenneth Steele and colleagues reported three new experiments in three labs, built on the original design. Mozart “produced no differential improvement in spatial reasoning in any experiment.” In one lab the Mozart group scored 3 IQ-point equivalents higher than the silence group; in another it scored 4 points lower. Their verdict: “A requiem may therefore be in order.” Another of Steele’s studies, with 206 college students, also found no difference.

The scientist who found it never claimed it

Here’s the twist. Rauscher answered both papers in that same issue of Nature, and she agreed with the most important point. The common misconception, she wrote, is “that listening to Mozart enhances intelligence. We made no such claim.” The effect her team reported was limited to “spatial–temporal tasks involving mental imagery and temporal ordering.”

She still defended a small, specific effect, and pointed to studies that had found one. What nobody in this debate was defending was the idea that Mozart turns into lasting brain power.

Mood, not Mozart

So where did the small bumps come from? Mostly from how people felt.

One study Chabris described let people listen either to Mozart or to a passage from a Stephen King story. Both helped on a paper-folding task, but only for the listeners who enjoyed what they heard. Another, run with 8,120 British schoolchildren, found that pop music did better than Mozart.

Then in 2001, the psychologists Thompson, Schellenberg and Husain tested the idea directly. People did a spatial test after silence, after a “pleasant and energetic” Mozart sonata, or after a slow, sad adagio by Albinoni. Only Mozart helped. But once the researchers accounted for how much each listener enjoyed the music and how aroused and cheerful they felt, the Mozart effect disappeared. Their conclusion: it is “an artifact of arousal and mood.”

That has a nice everyday reading. Something you enjoy wakes you up a little, and for a few minutes you may do slightly better at a puzzle. It isn’t Mozart’s magic, and it doesn’t last.

From students to babies

How did a small, short-lived result about college students become advice for parents? The psychologists Bangerter and Heath tracked the story through the press and found it held media attention longer than other science news, especially when it showed up in events outside science. By then the legend had become, in their words, “the idea that listening to classical music enhances intelligence”, and its content kept changing as it spread.

One such event came in January 1998, when Georgia’s governor Zell Miller proposed $105,000 a year to give every child born in the state a tape or CD of classical music, as Wikipedia’s account of a New York Times report describes. He played legislators some Beethoven and asked: “Now, don’t you feel smarter already?”

A 2023 paper by Sandra Oberleiter and Jakob Pietschnig puts the arc plainly: the original effect was “ultimately demonstrated to be a consequence of low study power and bias-related measurement artifacts”, yet claims of lasting intelligence boosts, “especially in children”, made it popular, with a small industry selling music that supposedly makes you cleverer.

You’re in very good company

If you picked “yes”, most people around you did too. In a US survey published in 2017, 59% of 3,045 members of the public said “Listening to classical music increases children’s reasoning ability” was true. So did 55% of 598 educators, and even 43% of 234 people with a lot of neuroscience training.

So put on Mozart because the sonata is a joy: two pianos racing each other through an allegro con spirito. That’s reason enough. Just don’t expect it to do your homework.