The Moon has to be in front of the Sun

A solar eclipse is the Moon getting in the way of the Sun. For that to happen, the Moon has to be on the same side of Earth as the Sun, between us and it.

That position has a name: new Moon. NASA says it plainly: “Solar eclipses only occur during the new moon, when the Moon and Sun are aligned on the same side of Earth (in other words, when the Moon is in the daytime sky).” At new Moon the Sun lights the far side of the Moon, and the side facing us is in night. That’s why a new Moon is invisible, and why the Moon looks like a black disc during an eclipse: you are looking at its night side.

The giveaway: when does a full Moon rise?

A full Moon looks full because we see its whole sunlit half. For that, the Moon has to be on the opposite side of Earth from the Sun. NASA’s Moon phases page puts it in one line: “A full Moon rises at sunset; a new Moon is up all day.”

So a full Moon is rising in the east just as the Sun sets in the west. The two are on opposite sides of the sky. A full Moon can’t cover the Sun, because it is never anywhere near it.

So why isn’t there an eclipse every month?

There’s a new Moon about once a month, but most new Moons pass without an eclipse. The Moon’s orbit is tilted by about five degrees against the plane that Earth and the Sun are in (5.145°, says NASA’s Moon fact sheet). NASA again: “During the new moon, the Moon usually passes below or above the Sun, and its shadow misses Earth.” Only twice a year, in the “eclipse seasons”, does a new Moon line up well enough to cast its shadow on Earth.

Even then it has to be a good fit. The Sun is about 400 times bigger than the Moon and about 400 times farther away, so the two look almost the same size in our sky. When the Moon is near its farthest point from Earth, it looks slightly too small, and you get an annular eclipse: a ring of Sun around a dark Moon.

A total eclipse happens somewhere on Earth about every year and a half, but any one spot gets one only about every 375 years on average. The next one, on 2 August 2027, crosses southern Spain, North Africa, Saudi Arabia and Yemen. It will happen at new Moon, of course.

The eclipse that does happen at full Moon

The answer most people pick isn’t random. There is an eclipse that needs a full Moon: a lunar eclipse. NASA explains that “lunar eclipses occur at the full moon phase”, when Earth is between the Sun and the Moon and Earth’s shadow falls on the Moon, sometimes turning it red for a few hours.

So the two eclipses are mirror images. In a solar eclipse the Moon is in the middle and blocks the Sun (new Moon). In a lunar eclipse Earth is in the middle and its shadow covers the Moon (full Moon). Mix the two up, and “full Moon” feels like the eclipse answer.

Why the myth feels so right

The full Moon is the famous one. It’s the Moon in pictures, the one we notice, and it’s the Moon of “blood moon” eclipses. A Moon you can’t even see feels like an odd thing to block the Sun with. But that is exactly the point: we can’t see a new Moon because its lit side faces the Sun, and that is the side that does the blocking.

You’re in big company. In a study published in 2000, Ricardo Trumper asked 76 students starting a university astronomy course in Israel: “In order to have a total solar eclipse the Moon must be in what phase?” 71.1% said full. Only 22.4% chose new. Trumper called it “a discouraging result”, because more than half of the same class had correctly explained the phases of the Moon. He also notes an earlier study of university students in which 28% got this question right.

If you picked full Moon, you now know something most of that class didn’t. And if you ever stand in the path of a total eclipse, you can tell the people next to you that they are looking at the Moon’s night side.