Follow the atoms
Fat doesn’t simply vanish, because nothing made of atoms does. So in 2014 the physicist Ruben Meerman and Andrew Brown, a professor in the University of New South Wales’s School of Biotechnology and Biomolecular Sciences, asked a very literal question in the BMJ: where does every atom in lost fat end up?
Body fat is stored as triglyceride, a molecule built from carbon, hydrogen and oxygen. A typical one has the formula C₅₅H₁₀₄O₆. When your body burns it completely, the whole chain of steps adds up to this:
C₅₅H₁₀₄O₆ + 78 O₂ → 55 CO₂ + 52 H₂O + energy
In plain words: fat plus oxygen gives carbon dioxide, water and energy. To burn 10 kg of fat, the authors calculate, you breathe in 29 kg of oxygen, and you produce 28 kg of carbon dioxide and 11 kg of water.
Where each atom leaves
The carbon is easy: it leaves as carbon dioxide, through the lungs. The hydrogen leaves as water. The puzzle is the six oxygen atoms in each fat molecule. Meerman and Brown solved it with a 1949 experiment that tracked heavy oxygen through the body: the oxygen in body water and in exhaled carbon dioxide swaps back and forth so quickly that it ends up shared out in the same ratio as everywhere else. So four of the six oxygen atoms are breathed out, and two end up in water.
Add up the weights and you get the answer: 84% of the mass of lost fat leaves as carbon dioxide, and 16% as water. Of 10 kg of fat, 8.4 kg goes out through your lungs. The remaining 1.6 kg of water leaves however water does: in urine, faeces, sweat, breath, tears and other body fluids.
As the authors put it, the lungs are the main organ that gets rid of fat.
But doesn’t fat burn into energy?
It does release energy, and that’s exactly why your body burns it. But the energy comes from rearranging the atoms, not from the atoms disappearing. Every carbon, hydrogen and oxygen atom that went in comes back out, just in a different molecule. That’s why the authors say the “energy or heat” answer “violates the law of conservation of mass”.
The other popular answers miss for the same reason. The paper lists “converted to muscle” and “excreted in the faeces” among the misconceptions: burned fat leaves as carbon dioxide and water, and only the water part, about a sixth of the mass, can leave in pee, poo or sweat.
A breath at a time
The numbers in the paper make it surprisingly concrete. At rest, an average 70 kg person breathes out about 200 ml of carbon dioxide a minute in about 12 breaths. Each breath carries off about 33 mg of carbon dioxide, of which 8.9 mg is carbon.
Over a day spent sleeping, resting and doing light activity, that adds up to about 0.74 kg of carbon dioxide, and 203 g of carbon leaving the body. Swap one hour of rest for a jog and you breathe out roughly 39 g of extra carbon.
So, can you lose weight by simply breathing faster? No. The authors say this is one of the questions they hear most, and the answer is no: breathing more than your body’s metabolism needs is hyperventilation, which can cause dizziness, palpitations and fainting. In the paper’s own example, it’s the extra burning during a jog, not extra puffing, that sends more carbon out.
Why the myth feels so right
Two reasons. First, carbon dioxide is invisible. “None of this is obvious to people because the carbon dioxide gas we exhale is invisible,” Meerman told UNSW’s newsroom. Second, weight loss is almost always explained in energy terms: calories in, calories out. The authors suspect that the “energy in/energy out” mantra, and the way biochemistry courses focus on energy, is where the misconception comes from. Talking only about energy makes it easy to forget the stuff the energy was stored in.
You’re in very good company
Meerman and Brown asked 50 family doctors, 50 dietitians and 50 personal trainers: “When somebody loses weight, where does it go?” In all three groups, the most common answer was energy or heat. Across the 150, more than half gave that answer. Others said faeces, sweat and urine, or muscle. In the chart in the paper, the right answer, carbon dioxide, shows up only among the dietitians, and only a few of them.
So if you picked “energy and heat”, you picked the answer most of the experts gave. The fun part is what you get in exchange: every time you breathe out, a little of you goes with it.