The short answer
Nobody is left-brained or right-brained. The two halves of your brain really do specialise, and in most people language leans heavily on the left. But when researchers scanned more than a thousand brains looking for people who run mostly on one side, they didn’t find them. The “logical left, creative right” personality types come from a popular retelling of real research, and the scientist behind that research warned against them in his Nobel lecture.
If you believed it, you’re in very good company. In one survey, 91% of UK teachers did too (try the question yourself). This page is the longer story: what the split-brain experiments showed, how they became a personality quiz, and what the two hemispheres actually do.
The patients with two separate halves
In the early 1960s, the Los Angeles neurosurgeons Joseph Bogen and Philip Vogel treated a few people with severe epilepsy by cutting the corpus callosum, the band of fibres that joins the two hemispheres. In Roger Sperry’s words, it was “a last resort effort to control severe, intractable epilepsy”, and it “severed all neural cross connections for direct communication between the two hemispheres” (Sperry’s Nobel lecture). That band is the largest white-matter structure in the brain, with 200 to 300 million nerve fibres (Wikipedia).
Sperry’s lab at Caltech found a clever way to talk to each half on its own. Each hemisphere sees the opposite side of the visual field, so a word flashed briefly to the left reaches only the right hemisphere. The patients’ left hemispheres could speak and write as usual. Their right hemispheres were “largely mute”, but they weren’t stupid. They understood spoken words “at a moderately high level” and could read words flashed to them, which the patients showed with the left hand by picking out or pointing to the matching object (Sperry).
That was the real surprise. Before these tests, doctors had pictured the right hemisphere as a junior partner. The Nobel Assembly’s 1981 press release puts it this way: the isolated left hemisphere is “analytical and computer-like” and can speak, write and calculate, while the right is “clearly superior” for “concrete thinking, spatial consciousness and comprehension of complex relationships”, and better at recognising melodies and voices. Sperry received half of that year’s Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discoveries concerning “the functional specialization of the cerebral hemispheres”.
Notice who those results are about: people whose two halves could no longer talk to each other.
Sperry’s own warning
By 1981 the split-brain findings had already escaped the lab. In his Nobel lecture, Sperry mentioned the “growing wave of semipopular extrapolations and speculations concerning ‘left-brain’ vs. ‘right-brain’ functions” and said they “call for a word of caution”. Then he wrote the sentence that could stand as this page’s summary:
“The left-right dichotomy in cognitive mode is an idea with which it is very easy to run wild.”
He added that in the normal brain “the two hemispheres appear to work closely together as a unit, rather than one being turned on while the other idles” (Sperry).
How it became a personality type
The ideas spread anyway. Betty Edwards’s 1979 book Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain, in its fourth edition by 2012 and translated into many languages, built a drawing course partly on the hemisphere research. Edwards was more careful than her title: she called her two ways of seeing “L-mode” (verbal, analytic) and “R-mode” (visual, perceptual) to sidestep the question of where in the brain they sit (Wikipedia). But it’s the title that people remember.
In 1987 the psychologist Terence Hines argued that the research itself was sound but that commercial promoters were applying it to products and management training far outside what it showed (Wikipedia summarises his paper). Schools picked it up too. In a 2012 survey, 91% of the UK teachers and 86% of the Dutch teachers who took part agreed that “differences in hemispheric dominance (left brain, right brain) can help explain individual differences amongst learners”. The UK teachers also reported meeting left brain/right brain learning programmes in their schools more often than the Dutch teachers did.
What a thousand brain scans found
If some people really were left-brained, their brains should show it. In 2013 Jared Nielsen, Jeffrey Anderson and colleagues at the University of Utah tested exactly that in resting-state scans of 1,011 people aged 7 to 29. They split the brain’s grey matter into 7,266 regions and measured, for each connection, whether it was stronger on the left or on the right.
They did find lopsided networks. Nine hubs leaned left, including the classic language areas (Broca’s and Wernicke’s) and parts of the default mode network, which is busy when the mind turns inward. Eleven hubs leaned right, mostly in the network that steers attention. What they didn’t find was lopsided people. A person with one strongly left-leaning connection wasn’t more left-leaning across the board. Lateralization, the authors concluded, is “a local rather than global property of brain networks”, and their data “are not consistent with a whole-brain phenotype of greater ‘left-brained’ or greater ‘right-brained’ network strength across individuals.”
Two honest limits. These were scans of people resting, not doing tasks, and the shared data came without personality or behaviour scores, which the authors list as a limitation. So the study didn’t test creativity directly. What it showed is that the thing the myth needs, a brain that runs mostly on one side, didn’t turn up in a thousand brains.
What really is lopsided
Language is the clearest case. A 2000 study in the journal Brain measured blood flow to each hemisphere while 326 healthy people thought of words. Right-hemisphere language dominance turned up in 4% of strong right-handers, 15% of ambidextrous people and 27% of strong left-handers (Knecht et al. 2000). So even among strong left-handers, most don’t have their language on the right.
Maths, the supposed left-brain skill, shows how messy the split is. Exact arithmetic leans on language-like networks, but the sense of size and quantity behind approximate arithmetic “recruits bilateral areas of the parietal lobes”, the same regions used for visual and spatial thinking (Dehaene et al. 1999). The authors suggest mathematical intuition may come from the two systems working together. Even in Sperry’s patients, the press release notes, the right hemisphere could still add small numbers.
So specialisation is real, graded and local. It’s about particular jobs, such as producing words or steering attention, not about what kind of person you are.
Why the story is so easy to believe
It starts from something true, and Sperry’s Nobel Prize makes it sound authoritative. It gives you two neat boxes, and either label sounds like a compliment. And it’s hard to test on yourself: you can’t feel which side of your head is doing the work.
That combination is exactly what Feynman warned about when he said the first principle is not to fool yourself. A story that is half right, flattering and untestable from the inside is the easiest kind to keep.
What to keep instead
If you think of yourself as a numbers person or a creative type, nothing here takes that away. As Robert Shmerling of Harvard Health Publishing puts it, the research “doesn’t change anything”, but it’s “probably inaccurate” to link those traits to one side of your brain.
Sperry himself ended his lecture on a better idea than left and right. The more researchers learned, he wrote, the more it seemed that the “unique individuality in our brain networks makes that of fingerprints or facial features appear gross and simple by comparison” (Sperry). You don’t have a dominant half. You have one brain, wired in its own way, and both halves are in on everything you do.
Comments 0
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.